What to Eat When Your Gut Feels Broken

The Tummy Clinic | July 11th, 2025

When your gut flares up, it can feel like everything is off-limits. Even simple foods don’t sit right. You start skipping meals, second-guessing snacks, and wondering if you’ll ever feel confident eating again. We want you to know: this is a common place to land. But it’s not where you have to stay.

The Loss of Food Confidence

We often hear patients say:

“I feel like I can’t eat anything.”
“Everything bothers me.”
“Even safe foods aren’t safe anymore.”

When the gut is flaring, food can start to feel dangerous. You may find yourself narrowing your diet more and more—not because a provider told you to, but because your body seems to react to everything.

And eventually, you might reach the point where you don’t know what’s left.

We call this food fear burnout. And it’s one of the hardest parts of living with a Disorder of Gut–Brain Interaction (DGBI) like IBS.

Why Nothing Feels Safe

In IBS and other DGBIs, the issue often isn’t what you ate—it’s how the gut is processing signals in the moment:

  • Motility may be off (too fast or too slow)
  • Visceral nerves may be hypersensitive
  • The gut might be holding tension, or reacting to stress
  • There may be trapped gas or pressure affecting sensation

All of this means the same food that felt okay last week may feel awful today.

This inconsistency is what makes food feel so confusing—and what makes typical food journals or rigid elimination diets deeply unhelpful in flare phases.

What Can You Eat When Everything Feels Wrong?

We approach this gently. When the gut is flaring, we don’t believe in perfection. We believe in:

  • Soothing textures
  • Simple structure
  • Regular rhythm
  • Supportive pacing

And sometimes that means:

  • A warm smoothie when chewing feels like too much
  • Cooked vegetables instead of raw
  • A small bowl of rice with soft proteins and roasted squash
  • Nourishment that feels neutral—not triggering

We’re not talking about a cleanse. We’re talking about calm, low-effort meals that give your gut time to recalibrate.

The Goal Isn’t Restriction—It’s Rebuilding

When people ask us, “What should I eat when I feel broken?” we don’t give them a long list of rules. We start with care.

  • Eat something.
  • Eat something soft or simple.
  • Eat something that feels neutral—not alarming.
  • Then do it again tomorrow.

Because what actually helps in a flare is re-establishing rhythm and reducing alarm—not finding a magic food.

And it’s okay if the meal is plain. Sometimes a small bowl of well-cooked rice, roasted squash, and soft chicken does more for your gut than any “perfect” plan. Especially if it brings a sense of calm and allows your digestion to reset gently.

This is about nourishment without overwhelm—supporting the microbiome through consistency, variety over time, and a return to safety in the body.

You Can Come Back From This

If you’re in the place where nothing feels safe to eat, know this:
We’ve seen hundreds of patients in that place—and we’ve helped them find their way back.

Not by overcorrecting. Not by giving them 30 new foods to try next week.
But by offering the right map, the right support, and enough time to rebuild food trust again.

Your gut isn’t broken. It’s just overwhelmed. And with the right kind of care, it can begin to feel safe again.

Frequently Asked Questions

Managing IBS with diarrhea can be challenging, but making the right food choices can help. Here’s what works for many people with IBS:

  • Low FODMAP diet: This dietary approach helps reduce symptoms like diarrhea, bloating, and stomach pain. It involves removing certain foods and gradually reintroducing them to see which ones trigger your symptoms.
  • Easy-to-digest foods: Stick with foods like plain rice, cooked carrots, zucchini, and lean proteins (e.g., chicken, fish) to ease digestion.
  • Avoiding triggers: Steer clear of fatty, spicy, or fried foods, as well as dairy and caffeine. These can worsen symptoms for many people with IBS.

If you’re unsure which foods work for you, consulting with a healthcare provider can help you create a personalized meal plan.

Bloating, gas, and stomach pain are common in IBS. These symptoms often result from:

  • Gas buildup: Undigested food or fermentation in the intestines can cause gas and bloating.
  • Gut motility issues: In IBS, food may move too quickly or slowly through the digestive tract, leading to discomfort.
  • Food sensitivities: Certain foods like high FODMAP foods can cause bloating or pain.

Managing these symptoms typically involves diet modifications, stress management, and finding the foods that work best for your body.

IBS constipation can be tough, but there are ways to improve bowel movements:

  • Increase soluble fiber: Foods like oats, bananas, and carrots can help soften stool.
  • Stay hydrated: Drinking plenty of water helps keep things moving.
  • Exercise regularly: Physical activity helps stimulate digestion.

If these strategies don’t work, gentle laxatives or stool softeners might be considered, but always under the guidance of a healthcare professional.

Certain foods can make IBS symptoms worse, including:

  • High FODMAP foods: These include foods like onions, garlic, certain fruits (e.g., apples, watermelon), and dairy.
  • Fatty foods: Rich, greasy foods often cause discomfort for those with IBS.
  • Caffeine and alcohol: These can irritate the digestive system and increase symptoms like diarrhea or bloating.

By tracking your food intake and symptoms, you can start to identify which foods are causing flare-ups and work toward a personalized plan.

Constant constipation in IBS can be caused by:

  • Low fiber intake
  • Dehydration: Not drinking enough water can make stool hard and difficult to pass.
  • Stress: Emotional stress often affects digestion and can contribute to constipation.

If constipation persists despite lifestyle changes, consider speaking with a healthcare provider for further assessment and potential treatment options.

Severe bloating can occur when:

  • Gas is trapped in the intestines due to difficulty digesting certain foods or fermentation.
  • Slow motility: In IBS, the digestive system may move food too slowly, leading to bloating.

To manage bloating, consider reducing high FODMAP foods and incorporating more digestive-friendly meals. Stress management techniques like yoga or mindfulness can also help reduce bloating by calming the nervous system.